Lindsay Olson

Just another WordPress weblog

How To Deal with Multiple Recruiters Who Work with the Same Company

582274247 1464d3e915 How To Deal with Multiple Recruiters Who Work with the Same Company

The 10th Kingdom dvdrip


Recruiter A put me in for Position 1 at Company X. I met with Recruiter B to discuss a potential Position 2 at Company X (although I didn't realize it until our meeting that the job was for Company X). I explained to Recruiter B that Recruiter A had already put me in for Position 1 at Company X, so we decided I should try to confirm with Recruiter A that Position 2 was NOT the same job as Position 1.

Before I could call Recruiter A, I received a voicemail from her telling me that she knew of another potential position at Company X (it was Position 2).

So, the "original" recruiter ended up asking me if I wanted to also be put in for Position 2, AFTER I'd already met with Recruiter B to discuss it. Recruiter B has not yet sent my information to the client.

What do I do? Recruiter A has already been talking to Company X about me for Position 1, so I am already in the running there. Recruiter B hasn't even gotten to that point yet and the two positions are very similar.


This is a tricky and uncomfortable situation for all involved, but the best way to avoid any problems is to be honest with Recruiter B and tell her you have already been submitted to the company by Recruiter A. When companies utilize the services of search firms, the service agreements usually state that once a recruiter submits a candidate for a position, the recruiter is entitled to receive credit for the introduction, no matter which position the candidate is hired for a period of six months to one year.

In this situation, Recruiter A clearly discussed opportunities at the company with you first and deserves credit (he's likely to be compensated anyways for the placement). Do not allow Recruiter B to submit your information to the company. Just kindly let her know that you clarified the situation and you have already been presented to the company.  Keep the door open to hear about opportunities with her other clients. She should be understanding to the situation. It's part of being in the recruiting business.

Problems arise when the same candidate is presented by two different search firms to the same company. Some candidates believe it is to their advantage to hide previous applications, past interviews, or discussions about the company with another third-party recruiter, so they deliberately omit this pertinent information. I imagine it's because many candidates are not well-versed on how the recruiter/company relationships works and they probably think the more people who put them in front of the company, the better.

This is not the case when working with recruiters.

The consequences of being introduced by more than one recruiter for a position will never result in a happy ending. It damages the relationship between the candidate and the recruiters. Most hiring companies will do whatever necessary to not be involved in a battle between two recruiting firms claiming credit for the candidate. The company will question the candidate's integrity or possibly decide that hiring the candidate will cause issues it prefers to avoid.

These situations can be easily avoided by keeping a few things in mind:

  • Keep detailed notes of the companies and positions for which you have applied, including conversations with recruiters and the positions/companies they have presented. Include position and dates of initial introduction and follow through interviews.
  • Be honest with a recruiter if you have sent your information directly to a company or if you have been presented an opportunity at the company by another recruiter. We don't like surprises.
  • Not all recruiters adhere to the same standards of confidentiality. Make it clear to the recruiters you choose to work with that your information should not be sent to any company without your permission.

This post is part of an on-going series

featuring readers job search and hiring questions. If you have a question you would like answered in this blog, please send it to me here. Your information will be kept confidential.

Photo credit: JPhilipson

Running on Empty Dreams trailer

share save 171 16 How To Deal with Multiple Recruiters Who Work with the Same Company

5 Comments - Add yours!

Biking Guidebook (April 2nd, 2010)

Solid article. There’s a lot of great info here, though I did want to let you know something – I am running Ubuntu with the up-to-date beta of FireFox, and the look and feel of your blog is kind of funky for me. I can figure out the articles, but the navigation doesn’t function so great.

Ray (August 31st, 2010)

Thanks for this post! I received 3 emails from 3 different recruiting companies about the same position. Now I know that I should just send my information to ONE of the recruiters. Only problem I have now is which one would best be able to present my information to them. I will have to do some of my own research to narrow down the choice.

J (November 16th, 2011)

So, what happens when Recruiter A claims that the hourly rate for the position is $45, but Recruiter B advertises for the same position claiming same said position to be an hourly rate of $55?
I have this situation currently and obviously, anyone who’s going for the job will want to receive the most money for the position as possible(within competitive industry rates).
Would you consider taking the information from Recruiter B and going back to Recruiter A to re-negotiate the hourly rate bast on what else is out there for the same position?

Honestly in this day and age, I’ve not encountered or heard of any recruiter putting the interest of it’s client employees first over their institutional clients.
Recruiters are out to make the buck and place the the candidates that are most likely going to be placed with the client.
No one seems to be looking out for the employee in this relationship.

R (December 14th, 2011)

What happens if recruiter A decides not to present you, however recruiter b does?

Chloe (January 12th, 2012)

What about when a recruiter contacts you for a job that is similar but not the exact job that you applied for through the company. Can they represent me if the job is not the same?

Leave a Reply

Register at Gravatar to show your image next to your comment in this and other blogs.

WordPressCreative Commons

© Lindsay Olson 2015 | RSS Contents | RSS Comments. Proudly powered by Wordpress. Web development by SocialSnack.